In May 2009, the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) received a confidential employee request for a health hazard evaluation (HHE) at a Florida oncology clinic, concerning possible employee exposure to chemotherapy drugs.1 Thus, NIOSH investigators began an evaluation of the site’s cleaning procedures and employee work practices. A site visit was conducted in September of that year, which measured the face velocity of the Class 2 biological safety cabinet (BSC) where chemotherapy was mixed, and surface and hand samples were collected for platinum-containing chemotherapy agents. In addition, NIOSH investigators conducted health interviews with 14 of 54 employees and reviewed the OSHA Form 300 Log of Work-Related Injuries and Illnesses for 2006-2008.
A second evaluation of the facility occurred in November 2010, when surface wipe samples for platinum-containing chemotherapy drugs were collected (in similar locations to the first evaluation), as well as surface wipe samples for cyclophosphamide, ifosfamide, and doxorubicin at the start of the work day, prior to unpacking chemotherapy, and at the end of the work day, after the last chemotherapy treatment was completed.
Results of the NIOSH Investigation
The results of these evaluations highlight important findings:
Investigators noted other interesting findings. Cyclophosphamide residue was found in the clinic pharmacy (on the floor in front of the BSC and the prepared drugs), in a treatment room (under an IV stand next to the first chair), and in the checkout area (on the desk surface). Although no spills or accidents were reported, it is possible that there may have been surface contamination or an undetected leak in an IV bag. The results from surface sampling in the treatment room were among the highest detected during the investigation, suggesting that cyclophosphamide was stable in that environment and that housekeeping procedures were not effectively removing this medication in one cleaning.
Moreover, cyclophosphamide was detected in all surface wipe samples collected in the checkout area, which is significant because chemotherapy drugs were not administered in the checkout area. This is particularly alarming, as employees working in this area do not wear PPE, and patients in the checkout area could unknowingly be exposed to chemotherapy agents outside of their treatment regimen. In addition, patients’ family members and the general public may be exposed. Although the source of chemotherapy in the checkout area was not identified, possible sources include contaminated paperwork, contaminated skin of employees, or patients themselves.
Based on inconsistent use of personal protective equipment (PPE) and the presence of chemotherapy residue in the clinic work area, NIOSH investigators concluded that employees were at risk of developing both acute and chronic health effects from exposure to chemotherapy. NIOSH recommended that the clinic improve employee work practices and housekeeping, start an employee medical surveillance program, provide annual training, and require the use of appropriate PPE when handling chemotherapy drugs.
Scope of the Problem
The Florida clinic’s deficiencies described in the NIOSH HHE report are not an aberration; many organizations struggle with reducing staff exposure to chemotherapy. Although safe handling guidelines have been established, adherence has been sporadic, and the problem of occupational exposure to hazardous drugs in hospitals persists. Measurable concentrations of some hazardous drugs have been documented in the urine of health care workers who prepare or administer these medications, even after safety precautions have been put in place. Likewise, environmental studies of patient care areas have documented measurable concentrations of drug contamination, even in facilities following recommended handling guidelines.2 Clearly, continued vigilance is required to reduce staff exposure to chemotherapy. NIOSH’s recommendations to the oncology clinic can be extrapolated and utilized to reduce hazardous drug exposure at other facilities that handle, prepare, and administer hazardous drugs.
Recommendations for Reducing Exposure
NIOSH suggested the clinic follow a hierarchy of controls approach to reduce staff exposure to hazardous drugs; this method groups actions by their likely effectiveness to reduce or remove chemotherapy contamination.1
Engineering controls reduce exposure to employees by removing the hazard from the process or placing a barrier between the hazard and the employee, and are extremely effective at protecting employees without placing the onus of primary responsibility on the employee.
Management-dictated work practices and policies to reduce or prevent exposures to hazardous drugs—also known as administrative controls—are effective contingent on employer commitment and staff acceptance. Routine monitoring and reinforcement are required to ensure that policies and procedures (P&Ps) are not circumvented. NIOSH suggests that safe hazardous drug handling P&Ps be reviewed with participation of administration and staff, and that on the basis of this review, a hazard communication program—ie, worker and employer right-to-know for all hazardous drugs used in an organization—be developed.
As illustrated by the NIOSH investigation of the Florida oncology clinic, chemotherapy exposure remains a threat to health care workers handling, preparing, and administering these drugs. Therefore, ensuring that the appropriate engineering controls, administrative controls, and PPE are in place to protect employees is necessary to reduce the chance of hazardous drug exposure. Moreover, remaining abreast of guidelines, conducting appropriate staff training, and implementing effective cleaning practices and a medication surveillance program can assist in protecting health care workers from exposure.
Jennifer Karpinski is a senior editor at Pharmacy Purchasing & Products magazine, and can be reached at email@example.com.
Enter our Sweepstakes now for your chance to win the following prizes:
Just answer the following quick question for your chance to win:
Entries are limited to one entry per person in any active sweepstakes.
Thank you for your entry.